For carvings with fine detail that need to survive shipping and daily handling, the chalcedony and quartz family (around 7 on the Mohs scale, no cleavage) is the most forgiving choice. Jasper adds opaque color and pattern at similar hardness. Obsidian gives the deepest black and a bright polish but chips easily, while feldspars such as labradorite and amazonite, fluorite, and soft stones like howlite each need more care. This guide compares the natural stones we use most across our wholesale crystal carvings catalog, from the point of view of the carver and the shop.
Four properties that decide how a stone carves and sells
- Hardness (Mohs scale) is resistance to scratching. It decides how well a polished surface holds up on a shelf. The International Gem Society puts household dust at about 7 to 7.5, so anything softer can pick up fine scratches over time if it is wiped dry.
- Toughness and cleavage decide how a stone breaks. Stones with no cleavage break along curved, shell-like (conchoidal) surfaces. Stones with cleavage can split along flat internal planes when knocked, which matters most on thin parts such as wings, horns and beaks.
- Luster and translucency decide what a buyer sees: light moving inside the stone, a mirror surface, a flash of color, or pattern on an opaque surface.
- Variation decides how closely a piece will match its photo. Natural stone varies in color, pattern and structure even within one block.
The stones compared
Hardness and breakage figures below come from mineral references (the International Gem Society, GIA and Geology.com). Design counts are from our catalog data as of November 2026.
| Stone | What it is | Mohs | How it breaks | Polish and look | Designs in our catalog |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blue chalcedony and other chalcedony | Microcrystalline quartz | 6.5–7 | No cleavage; tough for its hardness | Glassy polish, translucent; shade and banding vary | 54 and 30 |
| Agates (flower, moss, crazy lace and others) | Banded or included chalcedony | 6.5–7 | No cleavage | Glassy when polished; every piece patterned differently | 1–4 each |
| Rose quartz, Angolan quartz, amethyst | Crystalline quartz | 7 | No cleavage; brittle, conchoidal fracture | Glassy, translucent; internal fractures show as cloudy veils; amethyst often color-zoned | 31, 9 and 7 |
| Red jasper | Opaque, iron-rich microcrystalline quartz | 6.5–7 | No cleavage | Takes a bright polish; opaque, so pattern sits on the surface | 22 |
| Blue and green aventurine | Quartzite with reflective platy inclusions | 6.5–7 | Usually no cleavage | Fine sparkle (aventurescence); translucent to opaque | 19 and 11 |
| Black obsidian | Natural volcanic glass | About 5–5.5 | Conchoidal; chips easily on impact | Very bright, glassy, uniform black | 27 |
| Labradorite | Plagioclase feldspar | 6–6.5 | Two perfect cleavages; can break on impact | Color flash depends on how the piece is oriented to the internal layers | 6 |
| Amazonite | Microcline feldspar | 6–6.5 | Perfect cleavage in two directions | Blue-green with white streaks or a grid pattern | 8 |
| Sodalite | Feldspathoid mineral | 5.5–6 | Poor cleavage; brittle | Deep blue, vitreous to greasy; scratches more easily than quartz | 4 |
| Rainbow fluorite | Fluorite (calcium fluoride) | 4 | Perfect, very easy cleavage in four directions | Takes a high polish; banded purple, green and clear zones | 11 |
| Howlite | Borate mineral | 3–3.5 | No cleavage; soft | Opaque white, subvitreous | 7 |
| Serpentine | Serpentine-group minerals | About 3–6 (varies) | Works easily | Polishes to a waxy luster | 5 |

Which stones hold fine detail
Small projections fail in three ways, and each stone group is prone to a different one:
- Chipping. Brittle, glassy materials break on impact. Geology.com notes that obsidian is relatively easy to carve but lacks toughness and is easily broken or chipped. Crystalline quartz is also brittle, though harder.
- Splitting along cleavage. Feldspars and fluorite can part along flat planes. Geology.com describes labradorite's two directions of perfect cleavage as making it subject to breaking with impact, and the International Gem Society calls fluorite's octahedral cleavage “very easy.”
- Wear. Soft stones such as howlite (3–3.5) and much serpentine lose crisp edges and surface polish to handling and dusting faster than quartz-family stones.
For designs with thin, exposed parts, such as wings, ears, tails, beaks and horns, the chalcedony, quartz and jasper groups are the lower-risk choice. Fluorite, labradorite and amazonite show their color best on compact forms such as hearts, palm stones, spheres and rounded animals. Our catalog does list some winged designs in rainbow fluorite; if you order those, specify packing and plan to display them out of reach.
Polish and appearance on the shelf
Translucent stones such as chalcedony and rose quartz show carved depth best under light from behind or above. Opaque stones such as red jasper and howlite show the carved surface and pattern instead. Black obsidian gives the most mirror-like surface. Labradorite is the one to watch for orientation: its flash appears only from certain angles, so a carving's best side depends on how the block was cut. If you sell online, ask for photos of the actual pieces when the look depends on pattern or flash. Photos or video of finished pieces are available for approval on request.
Care and display notes for your shop
- Keep softer stones (obsidian, sodalite, fluorite, howlite) from rubbing against quartz-family pieces in trays and bins.
- Dust softer stones with a soft cloth rather than wiping hard; household dust is harder than they are.
- Fluorite is slightly soluble in water, so the International Gem Society advises never submerging it; clean with a warm damp cloth. It also notes some fluorite fades with prolonged exposure to light.
- GIA notes that some amethyst fades with prolonged exposure to strong light, so keep amethyst out of a sunny window.
Treatments to ask about
Several stones in this table are commonly treated in the wider market. Geology.com notes that carved fluorite ornaments are often coated or impregnated for stability. GIA lists amazonite and serpentine among opaque gems commonly impregnated with wax or plastic, and chalcedony, quartz and howlite among materials that have been dyed. Treatment changes care requirements and should be reflected in your product descriptions. These notes describe the wider market. Our carvings are made from natural stone. The stones are not dyed and not heat-treated. Two catalog materials are man-made and are labeled as such: goldstone (including blue goldstone) and terahertz.
Dimensions and weights refer to recorded samples; production dimensions, tolerances, finish, packaging and availability are confirmed with your quotation.
Single-stone collections make side-by-side comparison easier: see blue chalcedony, rose quartz and black obsidian. For a design in a stone that is not listed, see custom crystal carving.
